Over in Dave's "3 Inch Mullane" post discussion, John D. bartleson Jr. wrote:
> I have not seen a pristine Schenkl complete with a perfect sabot. Perhaps someone
> has such a speciman?
And Alwion wrote:
> I also don't remember a complete Schenkl [sabot] to look at, anyone got a mint example?
I do not have any digital photos showing a fully-intact Schenkl sabot, but three books show it.
Dickey-&-George 1993 Edition, pages 297, 418, 419, 424
Bell's book, pages 369, 370, 373, 374, 520
Melton-&-Pawl paperback, page 76
Also, one 3" specimen is viewable online, at civilwarartillery.com, under Field Projectiles > Rifled Projectile
John P. Schenkl's paper-mache sabot performed excellently until its secret "recipe" (telling the exact proportions of its ingredients was lost, due to inventor's J.P. Schenkl's accidental death in early 1863. The sabot's manufacturer tried to duplicate the formula but the resulting sabot was brittle and also tended to absorb humidity from the air, causing it to swell badly. To prevent the humidity-absorption, the manufacturer tried covering the sabot from top to bottom with a long sleeve made of zinc sheetmetal. But that didn't fix the brittleness problem, so Schekl projectiles rapidly fell out of favor with the Army by the end of 1863. (For example, only a very tiny number of Schenkls was used in the Atlanta Campaign.) Therefore, Hotchkiss shells became the predominant ammunition for 3" Ordnance Rifles in 1864-65 campaigns.
In some of the photos in the various books mentioned above, you will see two "soft metal" bands, one at the top of the sabot, the other at its base. The photo posted by Jim T shows that after the zinc sleeve was introduced, the bottom "band" was part of the thin zinc base-cover disc. One photo in the 1993 Dickey-&-George book, page 418, shows the long "full coverage" zinc sheetmetal sleeve. Also, it is very noteworthy that several photos in Bell's book show NON-DUG Schenklsabots bo bands and no covering of any kind on the sabot.
About "Fixed" Schenkl ammunition:
One photo in the Belll book (page 373) shows a pristine-condition non-dug 6.4"-caliber Schenkl which has a thick rope encircling it's tail-knob, right up against the paper-mache sabot's bottom. There seems to be no other purpose for that rope than tying on a powderbag.
Also, perhapsregarding "Fixed" field-caliber Schenkl ammunition:
About 20 years ago, a friend of mine (Jess Myer) dug a cache of about a dozen unfired 3" Schenkl Percussion shells, near Danville VA. Those unfired Schenkl shells had very-significant amounts of the sabot preserved on them. Each of them showed sizeable portions of canvas powderbag "fossilized" on the Schenkl sabot. Apparently the powderbag was either tied or glued onto the sabot's main body, because the canvas powderbag does seem to have extended "over" the sabot, not just affixed to its base. (And, perhaps that is the answer to how a powderbag was affixed to Hotchkis shells.)
Regards,
Pete
Regards,
Pete